Sign Up ! Forgot your password ?

Article from category: Local

Update with your comments: Should the Luxembourg church and state separate?

The Luxembourg association for the separation of church and state have raised their voices once again calling for debate on church and state separation in light of recent world events.

Published on 04/03/2010 by Adam Walder | Read 2326 times.

Luxembourg needs to be totally independent and the church remains in its place. That’s what the organisation claims the "Bündnis fir d'Trennung vu Kierch a Staat” claims.

The organisation for the separation of church and state returns to the forefront once again, with a subject extremely delicate for the church.

Rebounding from the revelations of paedophile priests in Ireland and Germany, the organisation calls on political parties and the Chamber of Deputies to hold more debates to find solutions for alternative finances and to teach students more neutral values.

The organisation believes that debates are all the more necessary regarding the position of the church in relation to topics such as euthanasia, abortion or homosexuality that they consider obsolete.

But should the church and state separate in Luxembourg?  What do you think?  Does religion have a role to play in the government or not?  What do you think?

Why not let us know your opinion.  Click the link and send us an email to: editor@station.lu

Or visit Station.lu on Facebook and comment on our page: Click here

We look forward to hearing your views.  Comments already received below:

____________________________________________________________________________

Your comments:

Dear editor,

In my opinion, I think the power and influence of religious organizations should strictly be kept out of political affairs everywhere in the world.

Considering the Luxembourg case, it would make special sense to keep the Catholic Church separated from politics, since nowadays, it only manages to represent the interests of part of its citizens. The Luxembourg population has come to be made up of so many different ethnical and religious backgrounds, therefore, decisions, that have an influence on our day-in day-out life and the country's future should not be influenced by any religious group.

I'd like to point out though, that I do believe a certain spirituality is a necessity for every human's well-being. As a result of that, every government or leading institution- being made up of human individuals - needs its members to believe in someone or something, in order to take reasonable decisions and function in a mentally healthy and humane way. However, this should happen on a private level, and thus have its influence in the variety of beliefs and convictions that decision makers represent.

A German and Luxembourgish citizen.

____________________________________________________________________________

At the risk of upsetting a great many people. "Yes" the church has no place directing states in this modern world, How many people in Luxembourg attend a Catholic Church regularly (weddings, communion etc not included). I suspect a small number so why should the even smaller number of church elders dictate the laws the masses must live by.

SW

____________________________________________________________________________

Moien,
As a resident of the USA, my opinion should not carry much weight in someone else's national concern, but I will give my opinion anyway, such as it is.
However, despite religion having little part in my life (my wife has also "become" agnostic and we raised our two sons with no religion - but have often discussed spirituality and the role of religion in other people's lives with them.)
 
I have mixed emotions for your country:
It was such a big part of your lives and I would hate to see your national character diminished by removing it. I also worry about the beautiful churches losing financial support from the government.
 
On the other hand, I wouldn't want to pay for any religion's infrastructure and upkeep. I don't ask for any support of my views and wouldn't expect others to pay for them.
 
My father's heritage is Norwegian where they are going through the same issues with their Lutheran church structure. 
____________________________________________________________________________
Twitter Facebook Bookmark and Share

Forum

See all topics

Magazine

352LuxMag #142 - OUT NOW!

  • Permaculture in Luxembourg
  • Top Ten Things To Do In The Snow
  • Win Justice plus Peter Hook & The Light Tickets
Indice Dernier Var. Var. %
BEL 20 2304.58 32.46 1,43%
DAX 6766.67 111.04 1,67%
CAC 40 3427.92 51.26 1,52%
Nasdaq 2905.66 45.98 1,61%

Traffic

A13 Sortie Differdange - 18 min. A13 Direction Differdange - 07 min. A4 Direction Esch-sur-Alzette - 08 min. A13 Direction Saarbrücken<br />Rond-point Hellange - 07 min.
Subscribe
Rss feeds
Media Partners
352LuxMag
Terms of use | Disclaimer